How to Prove Pregnancy Discrimination at Work
- Blog
- How to Prove Pregnancy Discrimination at Work
How to Identify and Prove Pregnancy Discrimination in and Outside of the Workplace: A Comprehensive Guide
Pregnancy discrimination is illegal yet prevalent. This guide helps you identify, prove, and combat discrimination based on pregnancy, ensuring you know your rights and the steps to take if faced with unfair treatment. Learn how to gather evidence, seek legal assistance, and protect yourself against discrimination.
One of life’s most precious and priceless moments is pregnancy, or at least it should be! The reality is that special moments like pregnancy and childbirth are often shattered by prejudice and discrimination.
It is against the law to discriminate against a person because of pregnancy, even still, people and employers all around the world discriminate in the workplace, medical facilities, and otherwise due to pregnancy every day!
If you are fired or treated unfairly at work or anywhere else due to pregnancy, you need to understand your legal rights and learn what you should do to seek justice.
Keep reading to learn what pregnancy discrimination is, how it affects employees in the workplace, what you can do if you have experienced pregnancy discrimination, and how our consumer protection attorneys can help you.
Pregnancy Discrimination Definition
A good starting point for proving discrimination at work based on pregnancy is to understand the definition of pregnancy discrimination.
Discrimination based on pregnancy can be defined as mistreatment or unfair actions taken by an employer against an employee due to pregnancy, childbirth, or any medical complication associated with pregnancy.
Examples of pregnancy discrimination include:
- Refusing to provide a job to a deserving candidate simply because of pregnancy
- Suspension or termination of an employee’s service upon realizing that they are pregnant
- Refusing to provide requested and reasonably necessary modifications suggested by a physician
- Discrimination and bullying in the workplace due to pregnancy
- Treating pregnant employees unfairly and differently from other employees solely because of their pregnancy
Understanding these examples can help victims identify when they are being discriminated against, allowing them to take the necessary steps like contacting consumer protection attorneys to protect their rights and to seek justice.
How Do You Prove a Pregnancy Discrimination Case?
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is very clear that the protection surrounding pregnancy provided by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, and the ADA is not limited to just current pregnancies. In fact, the EEOC includes past pregnancies, childbirth, and even medical conditions related to pregnancy
In many cases, proving pregnancy discrimination is not easy unless one has sufficient evidence to support the charges. Gathering evidence and building a strong case requires both direct and circumstantial evidence. Here are examples of each type:
Direct evidence of pregnancy discrimination
This concept involves presenting clear and straightforward proof of discrimination due to pregnancy without needing further interpretation. Examples include the following.
| Type of Evidence | Description |
|---|---|
| Manager's Quote | A manager explicitly stating an employee will be demoted or fired because of pregnancy. |
| Written Communication | Letters, emails, or memos that clearly cite pregnancy as the reason for denying promotions or opportunities. |
| Offhand Comments | Intentional, sexist, and insulting remarks by decision-makers about a pregnant employee. |
| Performance Reviews | Performance reviews that suddenly become negative following the disclosure of pregnancy. |
| Policy Documents | Internal policies or guidelines that explicitly discriminate against pregnant employees. |
| Witness Testimony | Testimony from colleagues or other witnesses about discriminatory statements or actions by management. |
| Recorded Conversations | Audio or video recordings of discussions where pregnancy is cited as a reason for adverse employment actions. |
These examples illustrate clear instances of pregnancy discrimination at work, providing direct evidence that can support legal or organizational action.
Direct evidence is often the strongest form of evidence, as it provides clear, undeniable proof of discriminatory intent. However, such evidence can be difficult to obtain, as employers may be cautious about making overtly discriminatory statements or actions.
Additionally, there may be examples not included in our chart since the examples provided are just for informational purposes.
Circumstantial evidence of discrimination
To infer pregnancy discrimination, reliance on circumstantial evidence is often necessary. This includes facts such as:
| Type of Evidence | Description |
|---|---|
| Inconsistent Reasoning for Termination | An employer claims to prioritize the "process" over sales numbers but fires a long-tenured sales rep a week after learning of their pregnancy for not meeting sales goals that were never set. |
| Discipline or Demotion | An employee with positive performance reviews and job offers is disciplined or demoted after the employer learns she is pregnant and feels she has become too 'mouthy'. |
| Comparison with Non-Pregnant Employees | Pregnant employees experience less favorable conditions compared to non-pregnant employees. |
| Timing of Promotion Decisions | A short interval between informing the employer of pregnancy and being overlooked for a promotion. |
| Negative Performance Reviews Post-Pregnancy Announcement | Performance reviews that become negative after an employee announces her pregnancy, despite previously positive evaluations. |
| Changes in Job Responsibilities | Significant and unjustified changes in job responsibilities after pregnancy disclosure. |
| Witness Testimony | Testimony from colleagues about differential treatment of pregnant employees. |
Circumstantial evidence can be just as powerful as direct evidence when it shows a consistent pattern of discriminatory behavior. It requires thorough documentation and often relies on the testimonies of colleagues and other witnesses.
The examples included in this article illustrate how evidence can suggest pregnancy discrimination, even if direct evidence is not present. Pregnancy discrimination may exist outside of these examples, and these are just some common scenarios where discrimination can be inferred.
What to Do if You Can't Prove Pregnancy Discrimination by Yourself?
The CDC documented that at least 20% of women have reported being mistreated when seeking medical care and otherwise. Pregnancy-related discrimination certainly exists!
Some people worry that they may not be able to actually “prove” that they’ve been discriminated against since discrimination cases often hinge on the proof that is gathered. Even when there is discrimination, victims sometimes lack adequate evidence to present to the court, and otherwise worthy cases do not go through.
It’s important to contact Consumer Attorneys when you suspect you are a target of pregnancy discrimination. Additionally, you should also document everything and provide those details to our attorneys when you contact us. We can help you investigate your case further and file claims with the EEOC and the court. Also seek guidance from local support groups and seek out free services when they are available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Pregnancy discrimination entails treating someone in a way that is negative or unsuitable for work because that person is pregnant, might become pregnant, or is on maternity leave. Specific forms can include promotion or training opportunity denial, demotion or termination, pay reduction, or unpaid leave. It also covers refusal to hire a qualified candidate due to pregnancy or denying reasonable accommodations related to pregnancy and childbirth. Understanding these various forms can help employees recognize discrimination and take action to protect their rights. It’s recommended to contact an attorney as soon as you suspect discrimination since filing claims with the EEOC and the court has time limits.
To fight pregnancy discrimination, you should record all situations that are questionable when you believe discrimination is present, ask for work modifications in human resources, when needed, file a complaint with the EEOC, and seek legal assistance immediately! Organizations should have clear policies against discrimination, flexible working arrangements for pregnant employees, and equal treatment of all pregnant workers. You can also join support groups and advocacy organizations for guidance and support in your local area. Regular training and awareness programs within companies can also help in combating discrimination by educating employees and management about their rights and responsibilities.
The CDC documented that at least 1 in 5 pregnant women have experienced mistreatment while receiving maternity care. Equally as concerning are the number of employees reporting discrimination in the workforce. As more people join the workforce, legal protections are continuously needed to ensure they are not fired or denied wage increases due to pregnancy. Continuous efforts are needed to enforce anti-discrimination laws and create a more equitable work environment. Studies and surveys indicate that discrimination remains a significant issue, affecting career advancement and financial stability. By understanding and addressing pregnancy discrimination, we can work towards a fairer and more inclusive workplace for all.
Daniel Cohen is the Founder of Consumer Attorneys. Daniel manages the firm’s branding, marketing, client intake and business development efforts. Since 2017, he is a member of the National Association of Consumer Advocates and the National Consumer Law Center. Mr. Cohen is a nationally-recognized practitioner of consumer protection law. He has a we... Read more
Related Articles
