Experian Tenant Screening Dispute: When and How to File

  • Blog
  • Experian Tenant Screening Dispute: When and How to File
Contact Us
1
2
3
25 Apr, 2025
4 min
2165
When you are denied a rental property, the reason may be your credit history

Experian RentBureau: Inaccurate Tenant Reports, Inadequate Dispute Process, and Consumer Rights Violations

Experian RentBureau is an Experian service recognized as the largest and most widely used rental payment database in the United States. Here are some key statistics highlighting its scale and impact:

36 Million+ Renter Profiles: The database encompasses over 36 million individual renter profiles, providing comprehensive insights into rental payment behaviors. 
10,000+ Data Furnishers: More than 10,000 property management companies, electronic rent payment services, and collection agencies contribute data to RentBureau, ensuring a broad and diverse dataset. 
Over 4.4 Million Rental Transactions per month: The system processes more than 4.4 million rental industry transactions monthly, reflecting its extensive reach in the rental market. 
Daily, real-time updates: RentBureau’s database is refreshed daily, providing up-to-date information on renters’ payment histories.

These figures underscore Experian RentBureau’s significant role in the rental housing industry, aiding property managers in making informed leasing decisions and helping renters build their credit profiles through consistent rent payments.

Experian is regulated by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which requires the company to ensure the maximum possible accuracy of the information it includes in consumer reports, including tenant screening reports. Under the FCRA, Experian is also obligated to investigate and address any inaccuracies promptly when a consumer files a dispute. Failure to correct false or outdated information can lead to serious consequences for the consumer and potential legal liability for Experian.

Experian RentBureau Tenant Screening Mistakes

Incorrect Rental Payment History: Rent payments may be inaccurately reported, such as marking a payment as late when it was made on time, or failing to report a paid-off balance altogether. This can negatively affect a tenant's rental history and creditworthiness.

Inaccurate Eviction and Criminal Records: In cases of mixed credit files, Experian RentBureau may mistakenly report evictions or criminal records that belong to someone else, unfairly impacting your rental prospects. Additionally, eviction records that are reported incorrectly or should not be included at all can significantly harm your ability to secure rental housing. Similarly, inaccuracies in criminal history, such as outdated or incorrect records, can also pose barriers to renting, as landlords may view these as red flags despite them not reflecting your actual history.

Experian Tenant Screening Dispute Process

While it may seem that filing a dispute with Experian RentBureau is simple and can be quickly done online, this is not always the case. If you noticed a mistake in your credit history or Experian or Experian RentBureau reported a criminal case that does not belong to you, it may have a significant impact not only on your current housing application but also spread and affect your credit reports from the other bureaus, as well as insurance and employment background checks. 

It is important to take the right steps and gather necessary documentation and details about the inaccuracy that impacts your rent application. 

1. Obtain Your Experian RentBureau Report

  • Request a Copy: Start by obtaining your Experian RentBureau report directly from Experian’s website or contact them to request a copy. You are entitled to a free report if the mistake impacts your rental application.
  • Review the Report: Carefully review the report for any inaccuracies, such as wrong eviction records, incorrect criminal history, or other tenant screening issues. Ensure the information listed is accurate and belongs to you.

2. Check Your Original Experian Credit Report

  • Review Your Credit History: Since mistakes on your RentBureau report could also affect your Experian credit report, it’s essential to check your original Experian credit report for discrepancies. A criminal record or eviction listed on RentBureau could show up on your credit report, potentially harming your overall credit score.
  • Obtain Reports from Other Bureaus: Similarly, inaccuracies could spread across other major bureaus, such as TransUnion and Equifax, affecting your broader credit file. Check your reports from these bureaus as well to ensure the mistakes aren’t repeated elsewhere.

3. Contact Consumer Attorneys for Consultation

  • It’s highly recommended to consult with an FCRA paralegal before starting any disputes with Experian RentBureau or the credit bureaus.
  • At Consumer Attorneys, we specialize in helping clients build strong, well-documented disputes and are prepared to take legal action if the dispute is mishandled or ignored. Our team will work closely with you to identify which of your credit files may have been affected by the inaccuracy and ensure that the error is corrected.
Don’t fight Experian Tenant Screening Mistakes Alone!
Help Is Available
Contact Us Today!

Is a Dispute with Experian Tenant Screening Required Before Filing a Lawsuit?

Most FCRA claims against Experian Tenant Screening Services are brought on the grounds that Experian failed to address disputes raised by consumers and correct the errors on the tenant screening report. However, certain information must be reported accurately, and misreporting it constitutes an FCRA violation. In such cases, a dispute may not be required to take legal action against Experian and seek compensation.

A consumer may have a valid claim against Experian and seek financial compensation under the following circumstances:

  1. If Experian Tenant Screening Services mixed your information with someone else's and reported credit accounts, civil, or criminal records that belong to another individual, leading to a housing denial, you may have grounds for a claim.
  2. If Experian reported criminal or civil records that belong to you but have been sealed or expunged from public access, you may have grounds for a claim.
  3. If your criminal or civil records were reported with inaccurate dispositions, case degrees, dates, or other details, you may have grounds for a claim.

At Consumer Attorneys, we have extensive experience in assessing and investigating Experian Tenant Screening errors as well as other employment and tenancy screening violations. And we know how important it is to take the best steps in a timely manner. 

How Our Attorneys Can Help You

1. Build a Strong Dispute
Our attorneys and FCRA paralegals will help you prepare a well-structured dispute backed by documentation and legal language that increases the chances of a successful correction. A properly submitted dispute is critical, especially when errors involve complex issues like mixed files or false eviction records.

2. Identify Broader Impact Across Credit Bureaus
We don’t just fix the error with Experian RentBureau - we investigate how the inaccuracy may have affected your other credit reports from TransUnion, Equifax, or other credit and background report providers. Our team ensures that all related errors are addressed and resolved across every agency reporting the same mistake.

3. Take Legal Action if Disputes Are Ignored
If Experian fails to correct the error or mishandles your dispute, our attorneys are ready to file a lawsuit under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. We’ll fight for compensation for any financial or emotional harm you’ve suffered - and Experian will be required to pay all attorney fees at the resolution of the case, you pay nothing out of your pocket.

Frequently Asked Questions

If there's a mistake on your Experian RentBureau report, you may be entitled to compensation under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Experian will have to cover your financial losses like being denied housing or a job, as well as emotional distress such as stress or anxiety caused by the mistake. Additionally, they will have to pay for your attorneys and court costs - you don't have to pay for fixing their mistakes.

To dispute an eviction or criminal record on your Experian RentBureau report, it’s important to gather documents that clearly show the information is inaccurate or does not belong to you. 
Court Records: that show that the eviction or criminal case was dismissed, sealed, or simply show the final outcome and details of the case. 
Proof of Identity: Include a copy of a government-issued photo ID (like a driver’s license or passport) along with a document that confirms your current address. 
Written Statement: Attach a clear explanation describing what is wrong, why it’s inaccurate, and what action you’re requesting Experian to take.

Generally, you cannot directly request your Experian RentBureau report from a landlord. The report is typically provided to landlords and property managers when they conduct a background check during the rental application process. However, you can request your own copy of the RentBureau report through Experian's official website.

This is possible because Experian credit reports focus on your financial history (e.g., loans, credit cards) while RentBureau reports focus on your rental history (e.g., evictions, rent payments). They pull data from different sources, so discrepancies can occur. Rental information may not always appear on your credit report, and vice versa. If there are inaccuracies, it's best to consult an FCRA attorney to resolve the issue.

Yes, you can sue without disputing if certain violations occur. If your information is mixed up with another person’s, such as someone else’s eviction or criminal record appearing on your report, you don’t need to dispute it first. You can file a lawsuit based on identity mix-ups. However, if the error is related to credit account details like payment history, account status, or balances, a dispute is typically required first to resolve the issue before taking legal action.

imageDaniel Cohen is the Founding Partner of Consumer Attorneys
About the lawyer
Daniel Cohen
See more post

Daniel Cohen is the Founder of Consumer Attorneys. Daniel manages the firm’s branding, marketing, client intake and business development efforts. Since 2017, he is a member of the National Association of Consumer Advocates and the National Consumer Law Center. Mr. Cohen is a nationally-recognized practitioner of consumer protection law. He has a we... Read more

Contact Us
INVESTIGATIVE ENGAGEMENT AGREEMENT

You, (“Client,” “you”), and Consumer Attorneys PLLC (“CA” or “we”), located at 68-29 Main street Flushing, NY 11367 (“CA”) , hereby enter into this limited scope retainer agreement whereby you agree to grant CA the exclusive authority to investigate your potential consumer law claim(s), including but not limited to potential violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”), Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“FDCPA”), Equal Credit Opportunity Act (“ECOA”), Electronic Funds Transfer Act “EFTA”), Fair Credit Billing Act (“FCPA”), and/or the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA”) (collectively referenced as “consumer protection statutes”). 1Please read carefully before signing:

Authorization

You authorize CA to investigate your potential consumer law claim(s) under state and federal consumer protection statutes. You authorize CA to contact third parties on your behalf for the limited purpose of investigating your potential consumer law claims. “Third parties” include but are not limited to consumer reporting agencies, creditors, lenders, debt collectors, rental agencies, employers, courts, and law enforcement agencies.

CA’s Exclusive Investigative Period

CA agrees to investigate your potential consumer law claims in good faith. By signing this agreement, you agree to give CA the exclusive right to investigate your potential consumer law claim(s) for the next 180 days (“Exclusive Investigative Period”). For the duration of the Exclusive Investigative Period, you agree that you will not communicate with any other law firm or legal representative about your potential consumer law claim(s). You agree to forgo any previously scheduled consultation or case review until CA’s Exclusive Investigative Period concludes.

Termination of Exclusive Investigation Period

CA agrees that the Exclusive Investigative Period may not extend beyond 180 days without your prior written consent.

At any time between the date of this agreement and the expiration of CA’s Exclusive Investigative Period, CA may inform you of the outcome of its investigation. If CA’s investigation reveals that you have an actional consumer law claim, CA may ask you to sign a formal retainer agreement. If CA’s investigation does not reveal an actionable consumer law claim, or if CA determines to decline representation for any other reason, you will receive an e-mail that states CA will not represent you in any further pursuit of your potential claim(s).

The relationship between you and CA automatically terminates at 5pm on the 180th day of the Exclusive Investigative Period or your receipt of CA’s written notice to decline representation, whichever comes sooner. At the conclusion of the Exclusive Investigative Period or upon receipt of CA’s written declination of representation, you are permitted to seek alternative legal counsel without penalty.

Nothing in this agreement should be construed as a promise or guarantee that CA will represent you in a consumer lawsuit at any point in time. CA reserves the right to decline to represent you for any reason permitted by relevant laws and ethical rules.

Your Involvement and Promises to us

You agree to meaningfully participate and cooperate in CA’s investigation of your potential consumer law claim(s). You agree to immediately inform CA if your mailing address, e-mail address, or phone number changes at any point during the Exclusive Investigative Period.
You agree to provide all relevant information, communications, documents, materials, and all other similar instruments to CA and its representatives during the Exclusive Investigative Period. You understand that your failure to provide all relevant information, communications, documents, and materials to CA during the Exclusive Investigative Period may hinder, delay or otherwise frustrate CA’s investigation of your potential consumer law claim(s).

You agree, under penalty of perjury, to provide complete, accurate, and truthful information to CA. All documents and communications, oral or written, past or future, provided to CA during the Exclusive Investigative Period and anytime thereafter are presumed by CA to be true, complete, and accurate.

Fees and Costs Incurred During Exclusive Investigative Period

CA agrees that you will not incur any out-of-pocket fees or costs during CA’s Exclusive Investigative Period. However, if CA agrees to represent you in a consumer lawsuit, CA may recover the fees and costs incurred during the Exclusive Investigative Period from the Defendant pursuant to a future settlement or judgment.

You agree that CA has a right to place a lien on any future monetary recovery obtained by client related to the claims identified during CA’s Exclusive Investigative Period or as a result of CA’s investigative efforts. If you refuse to cooperate with CA in the formal pursuit of the consumer law claim(s) it identifies during or after the Exclusive Investigative Period, you agree that CA has the right to recover the fees and costs it incurred while investigating your potential consumer law claim(s).

Authorization to Use Your Electronic Signature

CA will send you any and all documents that require your signature. You authorize CA to affix your electronic signature to requests, disclosures, or other forms that CA deems reasonably necessary to the investigation of your potential consumer law claim(s) upon receipt of your approval or after the 7th day after the document was sent to you, whichever comes first. Your electronic signature will be used on any and all other subsequent documents that will need signature, affirmation, acknowledgment, or any other forms of authentication in reference to this matter under the above referenced procedure.

1You also agree to give CA the exclusive authority to investigate potential violations of state-specific consumer protection statutes.

All Rights Reserved. Without Prejudice. CONSUMER ATTORNEYS

FORM # INV2025CA119

I have read and agree to the Privacy Policy, Investigative Retainer
Supported file formats:
RIGHTS END WRONGS
Free Case Review
Zero Costs and Fees to You.
You pay nothing. The law makes them pay.
Get started
Contact Us
Head Office NY
68-29 Main Street, Flushing, NY 11367
706 East Bell Rd., Suite 114, Phoenix, AZ 85022
Our social media
Our rating services
TrustpilotBetter Business BureauGoogle Business

Attorney Advertising - Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website is for informational purposes only and does not contain legal advice. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. See our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy for specific information about the use of our online services.

© 2025 Consumer Attorneys PLLC. All Rights Reserved.