Federal Court Reverses Medical-Debt Ban: What It Means and How to Protect Your Credit
- Blog
- Credit Reporting Inaccuracies
Federal Court Reverses Medical-Debt Ban: What It Means and How to Protect Your Credit
When Medical Bills Outlive the Hospital Visit
Most debt accumulates gradually. It builds over time, often following periods of financial strain, and affects credit little by little. Medical debt is different. Medical expenses tend to arise suddenly, from emergencies or routine care that unexpectedly escalates, and they’re rarely something you can plan for or control. The impact isn’t only physical or emotional, but financial as well. And even after bills are paid or insurance steps in, medical debt can continue to linger on a credit report, quietly undermining a credit profile you worked hard to build.
In 2024, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) tried to fix that by banning the reporting of medical debt. The rule, finalized in January 2025, would have erased billions in medical collections from credit reports and stopped lenders from using them against consumers.
But on July 11, 2025, a federal court in Texas struck it down, ruling that the CFPB exceeded its authority under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). The decision reversed one of the most consumer-friendly credit-reporting reforms in decades, and left millions wondering what happens next.
In this article, we’ll explain:
- What the CFPB’s medical-debt rule was designed to do
- How the Texas ruling changed the landscape
- What protections remain under state laws
- How to dispute and remove medical debt errors from your credit report
- How Consumer Attorneys PLLC can help you enforce your rights
The CFPB’s Medical Debt Rule and Its Promise
When finalized in January 2025, the CFPB’s Medical Debt Rule sought to reshape how medical bills appear in credit reports. Its goals were simple but sweeping:
- Erase roughly $49 billion in medical debt from credit files,
- Protect about 15 million Americans from score drops tied to health emergencies,
- Stop lenders from using medical bills to judge creditworthiness,
- Safeguard privacy by preventing health-related debt from being used as coercive leverage.
The message was as moral as it was financial: no one chooses to get sick, and a hospital visit shouldn’t dictate access to housing, loans, or employment. In today’s job market, these records are often scanned by automated systems. To understand how these technologies affect your rights, read our guide on AI hiring tools and FCRA duties.
Supporters praised the move as a long-overdue correction, since nearly 1 in 5 households carry medical debt, and it often stems from insurance delays, billing errors, or surprise charges. Critics, however, argued that the CFPB had gone beyond its statutory power, a claim that eventually convinced the Texas court.
The Court’s Decision: Rule Vacated, Rights Intact
The Texas federal court concluded that the CFPB lacked the authority under the FCRA to impose a nationwide medical-debt ban. As a result, medical bills can still be reported to credit bureaus, at least for now. But the decision did not erase your rights. While the rule is gone, the law is still on your side. If a medical bill you don’t owe is harming your credit score, a credit report lawyer can use federal law to require the credit bureaus to investigate and correct the error. Under the FCRA, you still have powerful tools to:
- Dispute inaccurate information on your credit reports.
- Demand investigations within 30 days.
- Sue if credit bureaus or collectors fail to fix proven errors.
Why It Matters: The Human and Financial Balance
Medical debt isn’t just an accounting entry, it reshapes lives. According to the CFPB and Kaiser Family Foundation, Americans collectively owe over $88 billion in medical debt. Among seniors alone, the figure exceeded $53 billion in 2020.
For many, these debts force painful choices: skipping medicine, delaying treatment, or taking on high-interest loans. The burden hits hardest among older adults, people of color, and low-income families who already face financial strain.
At the same time, critics of the CFPB’s medical-debt ban argue that removing this information entirely could distort credit assessments. Credit reports are meant to reflect a person’s complete financial picture, and excluding certain debts, even medical ones, may make it harder for lenders to gauge actual creditworthiness.
The CFPB rule promised relief and a path toward fairness for struggling families. Its reversal now revives an ongoing debate: how to protect consumers from the lasting harm of medical bills without compromising the integrity of the credit system.
State Protections: Patchwork but Powerful
Even without the federal rule, some states have filled the gap:
- California (SB 1061) - Bans credit bureaus from including medical debt on credit reports.
- Virginia (HB 1370) - Prohibits the reporting of medical debt and restricts collectors from leveraging it for credit decisions.
- Other states, including Colorado, Maryland, and New York, are exploring similar protections.
Meanwhile, the three major bureaus, Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion, voluntarily removed paid medical collections and small debts under $500. These measures help, but they’re not legally binding. One policy change can undo them overnight.
If you live outside states with such laws, you remain vulnerable to billing errors, duplicate collections, or data mix-ups. That’s why knowing and asserting your FCRA rights is essential.
How to Identify and Dispute Medical-Debt Errors
Visit AnnualCreditReport.com to access free weekly online credit reports from all three major credit bureaus.
- Duplicate listings for the same bill,
- Balance that insurance already covered,
- Paid off accounts still listed as "open",
- Debts entirely belonging to other people,
- “Deceased” notations.
Collect Explanation of Benefits (EOBs), insurance letters, payment confirmations, and correspondence.
Online disputes are often automated. A written dispute sent to Experian, Equifax, TransUnion, or other reporting agencies creates a clear record and protects your rights.
Type and print the letter, include supporting documents and ID, send it by certified mail, and keep copies of everything.
Bureaus have 30 days to investigate. If they “verify” an obvious error, legal intervention may be necessary.
Errors aren’t minor - they can block loans, housing, or employment. That’s why Consumer Attorneys can step in early, even when you’re just beginning to suspect something is wrong. We help investigate the issue, guide the dispute process from the start, and stay with you through every step. When violations are confirmed, we take action to ensure the problem is addressed properly.
Why Work with Consumer Attorneys PLLC
Handling medical debt disputes alone can be overwhelming. Letters pile up, responses are confusing, and even solid evidence can be ignored. Without persistence and a firm grasp of the FCRA, it’s easy to lose hope. That’s where Consumer Attorneys PLLC steps in. We go beyond sending dispute forms - we fight to ensure your rights are enforced and your credit history reflects the truth. With over 75 years of combined experience, our nationwide team understands how medical debt disputes unfold and how credit bureaus push back. Here’s how we help:
- Thorough audits of your credit reports to uncover every error and inconsistency.
- Strategic dispute letters grounded in FCRA protections and legal precedent.
- Active enforcement of your rights under federal and state law.
- Court representation when credit bureaus or furnishers refuse to comply.
- Long-term guidance toward credit recovery and financial stability.
The recent Texas court decision to strike down the CFPB’s medical-debt rule is a setback, but it doesn’t leave consumers powerless. Federal law, state protections, and credit bureau policies still give you the tools to fight back. If inaccurate medical bills are dragging down your credit, remember:
- Errors can be disputed,
- Abusive tactics can be stopped,
- And you don’t have to face this process alone.
At Consumer Attorneys, we stand by your side, enforce your rights, and help you rebuild confidence in your financial future.
We don’t promise overnight fixes. We promise accountability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. The July 2025 Texas ruling vacated the federal ban. Unless you live in a state with its own protections (like California or Virginia), medical debt can still appear and affect your score.
Absolutely. The FCRA requires credit bureaus to report only accurate data and to investigate disputes within 30 days. If they fail, you may recover damages.
Yes. The FCRA allows consumers to sue for inaccurate reporting, and the FDCPA applies when a debt has been transferred to or collected by a third-party debt collector and abusive or unlawful collection practices occur. Depending on the circumstances, successful cases may result in corrections, statutory damages (up to $1,000 per violation under the FDCPA), compensation for emotional harm, and recovery of attorney’s fees.
Not fully. Billing errors, delays, or misapplied coverage can still generate collections. Always confirm with both your provider and insurer, and dispute any misreported charges immediately.
Possibly. The Bureau may appeal or re-issue a narrower rule, and new legislation could codify protections. Stay informed through CFPB updates and legal-rights resources.
Typically, up to seven years from the date of the last delinquency, unless they’re removed through dispute, settlement, or state-level protection laws.
Nisan Zaghi is an Associate Attorney at Consumer Attorneys whose practice is dedicated to protecting consumers from credit-reporting errors, unfair debt-collection practices, and background-check inaccuracies under statutes such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Read more
Related Articles
R
ONGS™You pay nothing. The law makes them pay.
