Medicaid & Debt Collectors
- Blog
- Medicaid & Debt Collectors
Debt collectors who chase you for Medicaid-covered bills are breaking the law. Period. Here’s what to do about it.
Debt collectors have some leeway when it comes to contacting people. But if a debt collector tries to collect on an unpaid bill that Medicaid should have paid, they automatically violate the law.
If you’re a Medicaid recipient, you know that this program is meant to provide peace of mind, not a barrage of harassing calls from debt collectors. Medicaid is a state-funded safety net, ensuring that those who qualify don’t have to pay for essential medical care. Yet, some debt collectors ignore this fact and attempt to collect on medical bills Medicaid should have covered.
Here’s the good news: this is not just wrong—it’s illegal. If you’ve been hounded for medical debts Medicaid was supposed to pay, you have rights, and you don’t have to face this alone. Let’s walk through what’s happening, why it’s illegal, and how you can fight back with the support of the dedicated debt collection defense attorneys at Consumer Attorneys.
Medicaid and Medical Bills: What You Need to Know
Medicaid is a lifeline for millions of Americans, ensuring access to health care without the burden of medical bills. When you receive care as a Medicaid recipient, your medical provider submits claims to the state for payment. You shouldn't receive a bill for covered expenses as long as you were eligible at the time of service.
Sometimes, errors happen. A provider might incorrectly bill you instead of Medicaid or fail to submit the claim on time. Worse, they might send the unpaid bill to a debt collector, even though Medicaid should have handled it. The law is clear when this happens: you are not responsible for that debt.
Debt Collection and the Law: Your Rights Under the FDCPA
The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) is a federal law that protects consumers from abusive, deceptive, and unfair practices by debt collectors. Under the FDCPA, it’s illegal for debt collectors to:
- Mislead you about whether you owe a debt.
- Attempt to collect a debt you do not legally owe.
- Use harassment, threats, or intimidation to try to make you pay.
When a debt collector chases you for a medical bill that Medicaid should have covered, they are violating your rights under the FDCPA. Even the attempt to collect that debt is grounds for legal action.
When it comes to Medicaid bills, it doesn’t matter what time the debt collector contacts you or how they contact you—if the debt collector merely attempts to collect a debt Medicaid should have covered, the debt collector is breaking the law. Under the FDCPA, any effort to collect a debt you don’t owe gives you the right to take legal action.
The Relevant Laws
| Topic | Law/Regulation | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Prohibition on Balance Billing | 42 U.S.C. § 1396a(a)(25)(C) and related regulations | Medicaid is the “payer of last resort.” Providers must accept Medicaid reimbursement as full payment and cannot bill recipients for remaining balances ("balance billing"). |
| Eligibility Protections | Federal and state Medicaid regulations | If you were eligible for Medicaid at the time of service, you are not responsible for covered services—even if the provider failed to submit the claim correctly or on time. |
| Provider Obligations | 42 C.F.R. § 447.15 | Providers who accept Medicaid must consider the Medicaid payment as full payment. They can only charge approved minimal co-pays or deductibles. |
| Debt Collection Violations | Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) | Attempts to collect on a Medicaid-covered debt may violate the FDCPA if the collector misrepresents your legal obligation to pay. |
| Summary | Federal and state Medicaid laws and the FDCPA | Medicaid recipients cannot be pursued for debts Medicaid should have covered. Violations may lead to legal action under Medicaid laws or the FDCPA. |
Why Debt Collectors Target Medicaid Recipients
Debt collectors know better. They’re aware that Medicaid recipients are often shielded from responsibility for medical bills. So why do they still come after you?
- Negligence. The provider may have failed to submit your Medicaid information correctly, leading to unpaid bills being sent to collections.
- Ignorance. Not all debt collectors understand—or care about—the rules protecting Medicaid recipients.
- Profit. Some collectors gamble that you’ll pay just to make the harassment stop, even if you don’t owe the debt. Sadly, collectors know how vulnerable you may feel following a medical procedure and the upheaval that comes with it. A quick call asking for money might be fruitful. So they do it.
But none of these are a defense to the debt collector contacting you. It doesn’t matter why they contacted you, how they contacted you, whether someone else told them to, or whether they do it all the time. If a debt collector contacts you regarding a bill that Medicaid should pay, they violate the law. Period.
How These Violations Affect You
Being pursued for a debt you don’t owe isn’t just frustrating—it’s harmful. Here’s how:
- Emotional distress. Harassing calls and letters can cause stress, anxiety, and even depression.
- Financial harm. Some people feel pressured to pay a debt they don’t owe, draining already limited resources.
- Damage to credit. Debt collectors often threaten to report debts to credit bureaus, which could lower your credit score and make it harder to secure housing, loans, or credit cards.
- Lost Time. The time it takes to fix a snafu like this can be…significant.
If you’re experiencing these harms, you don’t have to suffer in silence. The law is on your side. Consumer Attorneys is on your side, too.
Meet James: A Fight for Peace of Mind and Justice
“James” is a hardworking professional who has always taken pride in maintaining excellent credit. (We’re using a pseudonym to protect his privacy.) His diligent financial management and careful planning had positioned him well for an important milestone: leasing a new car with a special rebate offer tied to an American Express credit card. But just as James was gearing up for this exciting purchase, he received an alarming notice from a debt collection agency. They claimed he owed hundreds of dollars for a medical bill that Medicaid should have fully covered.
Confused, James reviewed his records and confirmed that he had been a Medicaid recipient at the time of the medical service in question. He knew this bill wasn’t his responsibility. Still, the calls and letters from the debt collector persisted. Each communication was more aggressive than the last, and James was left feeling trapped in a situation he didn’t create. Worse yet, the collector implied that the debt might be reported to credit agencies, threatening his impeccable credit score and jeopardizing the car lease and rebate he’d worked hard to secure.
The Emotional Toll of Unlawful Debt Collection on James
The situation took a serious toll on James’s emotional well-being. Each time his phone buzzed with an unfamiliar number, his anxiety surged. He couldn’t shake the fear that this illegitimate debt might tarnish his credit. As someone who had always met his financial obligations, the idea of being falsely labeled as delinquent was both humiliating and infuriating.
The timing couldn’t have been worse. James was in the middle of a major credit-dependent process, and the uncertainty created by the debt collector’s actions loomed over every decision he made. His focus at work suffered as his mind raced through worst-case scenarios. Would this debt collector ruin his chances of getting the car he needed? Would he end up paying for a debt he didn’t owe just to make the harassment stop?
Speaking of time, James spent much of his time trying to fix the situation. The time he spent identifying who to call, calling them, spending time on hold, writing letters, researching, and generally worrying about the situation is time that James will never get back. Time is money, and James’s wasted time is something for which we (and many courts) think he should be compensated.
Concrete Damages: Emotional and Financial Impact
The stress wasn’t just emotional—it was financial, too. To ensure that the false debt hadn’t already damaged his credit, James paid $50 for a detailed review of his credit reports from Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax. Thankfully, the debt hadn’t yet been reported, but the unnecessary expense only added to his frustration. The thought of having to keep monitoring his credit, fearing the potential fallout from an invalid claim, weighed heavily on him. In many instances, the damage to your credit rating is immediate and significant, resulting in you not getting loans or getting loans at higher interest rates than you deserve.
James’s peace of mind and sense of financial security—hard-won after years of responsible behavior—were shaken. The collector's constant harassment and threats made him feel helpless, anxious, and angry. These emotions are forms of harm recognized under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), and James was determined to hold the collector accountable.
Justice for James Through Legal Action
James contacted Consumer Attorneys to discuss his options. Together, we filed a lawsuit alleging that the debt collector’s attempts to collect a debt James didn’t owe were deceptive, misleading, and unlawful. The lawsuit sought compensation for James’s actual damages, including the $50 he spent on credit monitoring and emotional distress caused by the harassment. Additionally, we demanded statutory damages and injunctive relief to prevent the debt collector from continuing their abusive practices.
The case resulted in a settlement. The debt collector agreed to cease all collection activity, and James received financial compensation for the harm he suffered. Most importantly, the settlement restored James’s peace of mind and sent a clear message to the collector: violating consumer rights has consequences.
James’s experience is a reminder that unlawful debt collection practices can happen to anyone, but you don’t have to endure them alone. If you’re being targeted for a debt you don’t owe, especially as a Medicaid recipient, you have legal options to stop the harassment and seek justice.
What to Do If You’re Being Harassed for a Medicaid Debt
If a debt collector is contacting you about a bill Medicaid should have paid, take these steps:
1. Confirm Your Medicaid Eligibility
Check your Medicaid records to ensure you were covered at the time of service. If you were eligible, the debt collector has no legal right to pursue you for the debt.
2. Request Validation of the Debt
Under the FDCPA, you can request written proof of the debt’s validity. This forces the collector to show evidence that you owe the debt, often revealing their lack of a legitimate claim.
3. Keep Records of All Communication
Save letters, emails, and texts from the debt collector. If you speak to them on the phone, take detailed notes. These records could be critical if you decide to take legal action.
4. Contact Consumer Attorneys
This is the most important step. We know the laws in this arena. We will review your case, stop the harassment, hold the debt collector accountable, negotiate a settlement with the debt collector, and, if necessary, take them to court. We offer free consultations and don’t charge fees unless they win your case.
This Sounds Like a Hassle….Is It Worth It?
When debt collectors violate the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), they can be held accountable for the harm they’ve caused. The FDCPA allows consumers to recover various damages, which may go far beyond the standard statutory damages of $1,000. Here’s a detailed look at what you may be entitled to if you take legal action:
Holding a debt collector accountable under the FDCPA isn’t just about recovering money—it’s about protecting your rights and preventing future abuse. When consumers fight back, it sends a powerful message to debt collectors that their illegal practices won’t go unchallenged.
If you’re being targeted by an aggressive or dishonest debt collector, don’t wait. Reach out to a consumer protection attorney who can evaluate your case, explain your rights, and help you pursue the full range of damages available under the law. With the right legal support, you can stop the harassment and achieve the justice you deserve.
Don’t Let Debt Collectors Bully You—Take Action Today
When debt collectors target Medicaid recipients, they often hope their victims don’t know their rights. That’s where we come in. At Consumer Attorneys, we’re passionate about protecting vulnerable consumers from illegal debt collection practices. We’ll fight to ensure you’re treated with the dignity and respect you deserve.
Our team can help you:
- Stop the calls and letters immediately.
- Hold debt collectors accountable for violating your rights.
- Seek compensation for any harm you’ve suffered, including emotional distress and financial losses.
- Support you.
We’ve handled countless cases like yours, and we’re ready to handle yours so we can stand by your side.
If you’re being harassed for a medical debt Medicaid should have covered, you don’t have to face it alone. Illegal debt collection practices are a violation of your rights, and you deserve justice. Contact Consumer Attorneys today for a free consultation. Let us fight for you while you focus on what matters most—your health and well-being.
Frequently Asked Questions
The FDCPA, or Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, is a federal law that protects consumers from unfair, deceptive, or abusive practices by debt collectors. It applies to personal, family, and household debts, including medical bills. Under the FDCPA, debt collectors must follow strict rules when contacting you. They cannot use harassment, threats, or lies to force you to pay a debt, and they must be honest about whether you owe the debt in the first place. This law also provides you with tools to dispute a debt and hold collectors accountable if they break the rules. If a debt collector violates the FDCPA, you have the right to take legal action.
No, debt collectors cannot legally pursue you for a medical bill that Medicaid should have covered. Medicaid is a state-funded program designed to pay for essential medical care for eligible individuals. If you were eligible for Medicaid at the time of the service, the provider is required by law to accept Medicaid as full payment. Any attempt by a debt collector to seek payment for that bill violates federal and state Medicaid laws and may also breach the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). Even if the provider made a mistake in billing, the responsibility does not fall on you. Contact a consumer protection attorney to address the issue.
If a debt collector contacts you about a bill that Medicaid should have covered, don’t panic. First, confirm your Medicaid eligibility for the service and gather any documents showing you were covered. Next, request written validation of the debt from the collector, which is your right under the FDCPA. Keep records of all communication, including letters, texts, and phone calls. Avoid paying or agreeing to anything before talking with a FDCPA lawyer at Consumer Attorneys. These situations can be legally complex, and an attorney can help you understand your rights, stop the harassment, and take appropriate legal action if the debt collector has violated the law.
Yes, you can sue a debt collector if they attempt to collect a medical debt that Medicaid should have covered. Under the FDCPA, it is illegal for debt collectors to misrepresent your legal obligation to pay a debt or pursue you for a debt you do not owe. The mere act of attempting to collect such a debt is a violation, even if the collector did not report it to credit agencies or harass you. By suing, you may be able to recover damages for emotional distress, financial harm, and any costs you incurred trying to resolve the situation. Consumer Attorneys can help you navigate the process and seek justice.
If you sue a debt collector for violating the FDCPA, you may be entitled to several types of damages. These include actual damages, such as reimbursement for costs you incurred (e.g., credit monitoring or fees paid), as well as compensation for emotional distress caused by harassment or anxiety. You can also recover statutory damages, which are awarded even if you didn’t experience financial harm, up to $1,000 per case. Additionally, the FDCPA allows you to recover attorney’s fees and court costs, making it financially easier to pursue legal action. In some cases, you may also be granted injunctive relief to stop further collection attempts on the invalid debt.
Daniel Cohen is the Founder of Consumer Attorneys. Daniel manages the firm’s branding, marketing, client intake and business development efforts. Since 2017, he is a member of the National Association of Consumer Advocates and the National Consumer Law Center. Mr. Cohen is a nationally-recognized practitioner of consumer protection law. He has a we... Read more
Related Articles
